TLDR – Is Dry January worth it? – Time magazine recently argued that Dry January is a mistake and that moderation is a smarter play. While they’re right that white-knuckling doesn’t work, the science tells a different story: people who participate in Dry January drink less all year and are more mindful of their consumption. The real problem isn’t taking a break—it’s how we take a break. When you shift from willpower-based behavior change to emotion-based awareness (which has a 75% success rate compared to 5-10% for behavior modification alone), a 30-day break becomes a powerful tool for lasting transformation.
The Dry January Debate: What Time Got Right (And Wrong)
Every January, the same pattern repeats. Millions of people commit to 31 days without alcohol, only to return to their old habits come February 1st. Time magazine’s recent piece argues this makes Dry January a waste of time—that we should skip the performance of virtue and focus on drinking moderately all year instead.
Here’s the thing: they’re half right.
White-knuckling your way through a month without drinking? That doesn’t work. Relying on pure willpower to abstain while your brain still believes alcohol relaxes you, helps you connect, and makes life more fun? That’s a recipe for failure.
But here’s what Time got wrong: the problem isn’t Dry January. The problem is the approach to Dry January.
The Science Behind Dry January Success
Research actually shows that people who participate in Dry January are more mindful of their drinking for the remainder of the year and tend to drink less overall. A study published in Health Psychology found that six months after Dry January, participants were still drinking less and reported fewer drinking days per week than before they started.
The key difference? It’s not about the 31 days. It’s about what happens in your mind during those 31 days.
At This Naked Mind, we’ve worked with almost 500,000 people who’ve completed The Alcohol Experiment. These aren’t people who white-knuckled their way through a month. These are people who fundamentally shifted their relationship with alcohol by changing their unconscious beliefs about it.
Why Behavior-Based Change Fails (And What Works Instead)
Time’s article suggests creating rules, designing your environment, and using willpower tricks to moderate. Set limits before you start. Alternate with water. Don’t keep alcohol within arm’s reach.
The problem? You can create all the rules you want, but they go out the window once you start sipping. Why? Because alcohol literally impairs your logical reasoning, critical thinking, and decision-making capabilities. You can’t drink responsibly when what you’re drinking removes your ability to make responsible choices.
Behavior-based change techniques have a success rate of around 5-10%. That’s abysmal.
Emotion-based change techniques? They show around 75% long-term efficacy.
The difference is profound. Behavior modification says “don’t drink” and expects willpower to bridge the gap. Emotion-based change asks “why do you want to drink?” and addresses the unconscious beliefs driving that desire.
The Connection Myth: Does Alcohol Really Bring Us Together?
Time argues that alcohol’s social benefits can outweigh its physical risks—that what protects our hearts isn’t the wine but the friends across the dinner table.
We absolutely agree with half of that statement: connection is everything. Research has shown that the opposite of addiction is connection. The famous Rat Park experiments demonstrated this beautifully—rats in enriched environments with social bonds didn’t choose drug-laced water, even when it was freely available.
But here’s where the logic breaks down: alcohol doesn’t create connection. It creates the illusion of it.
Alcohol is a depressant that makes us detached and less interested in those around us. It dulls our ability to be present, to listen deeply, to remember the heartfelt conversations we thought we were having. Study after study has now shown there is NO safe level of alcohol consumption—not for cancer risk, not for cognitive health, not for overall longevity.
So why take the risk of drinking if you can enjoy the same benefits—if not greater ones—by connecting with friends clearheaded? No cancer risk. No hangover. No fuzzy memories. Instead, you get deep conversations, stronger bonds, heartfelt laughs, and no regrets.
The Moderation Trap: Why “Just a Little” Doesn’t Work
The Time article suggests “dry-ish January”—tracking your drinking, understanding your triggers, but not actually abstaining. They call it an audit rather than a punitive task.
This sounds reasonable on the surface. But here’s what they’re missing: moderation is inherently difficult when you’re dealing with an addictive substance that impairs judgment.
It’s not that moderation is impossible for everyone. But if you’re someone who struggles with it, more rules aren’t the solution. Moderation rules are exhausting. They require constant negotiation, mental energy, and self-monitoring—all while your unconscious mind still believes alcohol provides something you need.
That mental load is what makes people feel deprived. And deprivation leads to bingeing, guilt, and shame.
A Better Framework: The ACT Technique
Instead of creating more rules, what if you examined the beliefs driving your desire to drink in the first place?
This is where the ACT technique comes in—Awareness, Clarity, and Turnaround. It’s a three-step process that enables you to unwind long-held beliefs about alcohol. When you shift your beliefs, making changes becomes effortless because you’re no longer fighting yourself.
How ACT Works
Let’s take a common belief: “Alcohol makes me happy.”
Awareness: You believe that alcohol is what makes you happy.
Clarity: Where did this belief come from? Turn on the TV and people are celebrating with alcohol. Movies, music, social media—we’re surrounded by messages that alcohol equals happiness. When we meet for drinks, we go to “Happy Hour.” Our experiences have created and cemented this belief.
But has that belief always been true for you? Have you always needed alcohol to be happy? Can you be happy without alcohol? What even is happiness to you? Breaking down and defining what we mean by “happiness” forces us to examine whether this belief actually holds water.
Turnaround: Find reasons why the opposite of your belief might be as true or truer. Does alcohol actually make you happy, or does it numb you? Do you feel happy during the hangover? What about the regret, the shame, the morning-after anxiety? Maybe genuine happiness comes from being present, connected, and clearheaded—things alcohol actively interferes with.
What Success Really Looks Like
Time asks: “Did I drink safely and intentionally all year?”
We ask: “Does alcohol still take up mental space in my life?”
Success isn’t about perfect moderation or hitting some arbitrary limit. Success is when alcohol becomes small and insignificant—when you can genuinely take it or leave it without negotiation or consideration of trade-offs.
Success is having a relationship with alcohol that feels good and doesn’t put you in a shame spiral of guilt, regret, hangovers, and self-criticism.
It’s waking up on Saturday morning with energy instead of a hangover. It’s remembering the entire conversation you had with your friend. It’s knowing exactly what you said and did the night before. It’s not wondering if you need to apologize to anyone.
Why 30 Days Matters (When Done Right)
If you crave a reset in the new year, a break from booze is an excellent way to get started. But not the white-knuckle, count-the-days, deprivation version.
What if, for 30 days, you’re not just abstaining—you’re learning? You’re examining your beliefs about alcohol. You’re discovering what it actually does (and doesn’t do) for you. You’re experiencing social situations, stress, celebration, and boredom without your usual go-to substance.
This is exactly what programs like The Live Alcohol Experiment are designed to do—guide you through 30 days of discovery rather than deprivation, with daily support and tools to shift your unconscious beliefs about drinking.
Most people find that relationships they thought required alcohol were actually just mutual drinking partnerships. They shed these surface-level connections and foster authentic ones instead. They discover that socializing isn’t just better without alcohol—it’s deeper, more meaningful, and more memorable.
The Truth About Social Connection and Alcohol
Time emphasizes that robust social connection is one of the most powerful protectors of physical and mental health. We couldn’t agree more.
Where we part ways is the assumption that alcohol facilitates this connection.
Think about your last conversation over drinks. How much do you actually remember? Were you fully present, or were you thinking about your next drink? Did you share your real feelings, or did alcohol make it easier to keep things surface-level?
Research on memory formation shows that alcohol interferes with the consolidation of episodic memories—the meaningful moments that build lasting bonds. You might feel like you’re connecting, but you’re not encoding those experiences in a way that strengthens relationships long-term.
Clearheaded connection is more vulnerable, more honest, and infinitely more rewarding.
Your Next Step
Taking a break from alcohol isn’t about perfection or punishment. It’s about curiosity and discovery—finally understanding why you drink and whether those reasons hold up under examination.
This January, if you’re ready to experience what life looks like when alcohol stops taking up mental space, consider doing it with support. The Live Alcohol Experiment offers 30 days of daily videos, tools, and a community of people doing it alongside you—transforming their relationship with alcohol through awareness, not willpower.
Because the real question isn’t whether Dry January works. It’s whether you’re ready to find out what clarity feels like when it takes alcohol’s place.
Learn more about The Live Alcohol Experiment
About Annie Grace
Annie Grace is the author and founder of This Naked Mind and creator of The Alcohol Experiment. Her work blends neuroscience, psychology, and compassionate habit change to help people transform their relationship with alcohol and, more importantly, with themselves. This Naked Mind is not here to shame your choices—we’re here to help you get curious about the beliefs behind them so you can build a life you don’t need to numb.
Copyright © 2025. All rights reserved. This Naked Mind and all associated materials are protected intellectual property. The information provided here is for educational purposes and does not constitute medical advice.